Ogbourne
Inbox2
Landscape
Remebrance-18-1
Marlborough-2013-04-18StPeters
MYFC005
IMG9097
EARLY-MORNING-CANTER-473-
4MI-2013-11-28030
Marlborough-under-snow-from-above---Pete-Davies
FROSTY-MORNING-
TdB-Pewsey044
Tina-May5
Hares017cropped
Turin-Brakes6
Brooks-Williams1
Remebrance-18-2
Sunset2
Remebrance-18-3
Camilla-2012-10-19152
Roving-Crows1
Christmas-Lights15-11-20097
Civic-Service-18
Bluebells-in-West-Woods-10-05-09------30
Torch-2012-05-23093-
MBORO-HOCKEY-YOUTH-473
Brazier
Inquisitive-sheep-in-West-Overton
Animals06
Musical-Time-Machine5
SBJ
Silbury-Sunset---10-06-08-----07
IMG8472
D4S0472
White-Horse
JazzFestSat572
Pete-Gage-Band1
Town-Hall-2011-05-0308-
Snowy-High-Street
1stXV-and-others-with-Mayor
Sunset
D4S9273
Big-Bull
D812668
Mop-Fair---10-10-09------08
YELLOWHAMMER-473-
BABRURY-XC-JUMP-473
George-Wilding-301
Camilla-MSM
Scouting-for-Girls7
Gordon-and-Sam
Inbox-1
Duke-of-Kent086

 

This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Unresolved disputes over funds between Wiltshire Council and Wiltshire's NHS commissioners could end with legal challenges

What appears to be a fairly bitter row has developed between cash-strapped Wiltshire Council and cash-challenged Wiltshire Clinical Commissioning group (CCG) over funding that was supposed to promote integration of health and social care through the government's Better Care Fund (BCF) scheme.

The dispute is a tussle over 'ownership' of some of the money - much of it transferred from Wiltshire's NHS budget to Wiltshire Council - earmarked to support social care and flagged under the BCF.

In September the CCG's Finance Director, Simon Truelove told the meeting of its Finance and Performance Committee: "Wiltshire Council recognised the Payment for Performance (P4P) position and would ring-fence and release the £1.2million, however the CCG should be mindful of the severe financial position of the Council and the political sensibilities around this."

At this meeting it was minuted that: "The CCG was confident in the leadership of Deborah Fielding (Accountable Officer) and Simon Truelove" on the grounds that "the biggest hospital deficits lined up with the CCG's deficit, so this position was not to do with leadership."

By October's meeting of this committee things were not looking so rosy:  Simon Truelove reported a "...difficult meeting with Wiltshire Council" regarding P4P and the underspend on the BCF.

"Currently," he reported, "the Council are assuming 100 per cent of the underspend to their bottom line which the CCG will not agree to.  Also Wiltshire Council does not recognise the P4P criteria, but this is essential for the CCG and must be secured."

Responding to the Council's adamant position, Simon Truelove had ordered "holding back the P4P element (£2.3million) from Wiltshire Council in line with national guidance."  And he had stopped "payments relating to the BCF completely until the dispute has been resolved."

He also told the committee that the CCG's internal auditors had failed to find any evidence that "the £2.3 million provided for additional adult social care (aligned to the care Act) has been used for that purpose." He added: "A legal challenge by Wiltshire Council is possible."

This is not the only dispute between the Council and the CCG over funds.  There is also an on-going spat over the continuing care of learning disability patients who, after NHS treatment,  become the responsibility of Wiltshire Council.  The CCG has been invoiced by Wiltshire Council for these patients - £634,000 for 2013-2014, £435,000 for 2014-2015 and £500,000 for the current year: "This issue may require arbitration."

The P4P money is seen as an incentive to complete schemes under the BCF, but can also be viewed as a contingency against the schemes not realising their intended savings or advantages.  In an effort to understand P4P a lot further, Marlborough News Online consulted the NHS England guidelines for the administration of the BCF.  Faced with incredibly complex rigmaroles written in NHS-ese, we failed to get any further enlightenment.

But we were left wondering whether in some respects the government's claim to have cut the number of managers and to have stripped out the much-touted bureaucracy is in the latter case somewhat bogus, and in the former counter-productive as the chase to make every pound work for patients gets more and more complex with each of the government's new schemes for the NHS and for social care.

As far as Marlborough News Online can discover, there has been no public airing of these disputes by Wiltshire Council.  The CCG committee was advised that they would be discussed at the Council's October Cabinet meeting.  If they were then there is no mention of them in the agenda or minutes for that meeting.

There is some anxiety that as the Better Care Fund proceeds with further money from the NHS budget moved to local authorities and social care budgets continue to shrink, disputes like these will become part of the landscape.  The government may need to find an independent body to regulate or adjudicate them.

The full minutes of the two meetings of the Finance and Performance Committee referred to above can be found here.   This dispute - critical to the future of the current NHS structure and to local authorities' ambitions for devolution and their take over of health service commissioning - has come to light now because minutes  of the CCG's committees are only published with board meetings which are held every two months.

Print Email

Animals06
TdB-Pewsey044
Big-Bull
Duke-of-Kent086
D4S9273
Brazier
D812668
Civic-Service-18
Marlborough-2013-04-18StPeters
Scouting-for-Girls7
Brooks-Williams1
Sunset
D4S0472
Gordon-and-Sam
Turin-Brakes6
Pete-Gage-Band1
Tina-May5
White-Horse
Town-Hall-2011-05-0308-
George-Wilding-301
IMG8472
Landscape
Torch-2012-05-23093-
Hares017cropped
Silbury-Sunset---10-06-08---07
Bluebells-in-West-Woods-10-05-09---30
MYFC005
Inquisitive-sheep-in-West-Overton
Ogbourne
4MI-2013-11-28030
JazzFestSat572
SBJ
Christmas-Lights15-11-20097
Camilla-2012-10-19152
Musical-Time-Machine5
Marlborough-under-snow-from-above---Pete-Davies
CivicSelfie1
Snowy-High-Street
Remebrance-18-1
Camilla-MSM
Remebrance-18-2
Remebrance-18-3
IMG9097
Roving-Crows1
1stXV-and-others-with-Mayor
Sunset2
Mop-Fair---10-10-09---08
ARKManton-2012-01-1449-