Remebrance-18-3
Bluebells-in-West-Woods-10-05-09------30
George-Wilding-301
1stXV-and-others-with-Mayor
Torch-2012-05-23093-
Marlborough-2013-04-18StPeters
IMG9097
FROSTY-MORNING-
Brazier
Remebrance-18-2
MBORO-HOCKEY-YOUTH-473
Mop-Fair---10-10-09------08
Christmas-Lights15-11-20097
Camilla-MSM
Town-Hall-2011-05-0308-
Scouting-for-Girls7
YELLOWHAMMER-473-
BABRURY-XC-JUMP-473
Camilla-2012-10-19152
Roving-Crows1
Turin-Brakes6
D4S9273
D4S0472
Marlborough-under-snow-from-above---Pete-Davies
TdB-Pewsey044
Brooks-Williams1
SBJ
White-Horse
Hares017cropped
JazzFestSat572
4MI-2013-11-28030
Snowy-High-Street
Inquisitive-sheep-in-West-Overton
Landscape
Duke-of-Kent086
Silbury-Sunset---10-06-08-----07
Civic-Service-18
Inbox2
Pete-Gage-Band1
Big-Bull
D812668
Sunset
EARLY-MORNING-CANTER-473-
MYFC005
IMG8472
Tina-May5
Animals06
Musical-Time-Machine5
Gordon-and-Sam
Remebrance-18-1
Inbox-1
Ogbourne
Sunset2

 

Lord Owen takes part in a fierce debate on military intervention

The second Bishop’s Debate organised by Pewsey Deanery and with Marlborough Deanery took place at St John’s Theatre on the Hill on Wednesday evening (September 14) with politician Lord Owen and the former Chaplain General of the army, the Venerable Stephen Robbins, opposing the motion “Military intervention in the affairs of other nations is wrong.”

L to R: The Revd Alan Deboo, Dr Colin Heber-Percy, Lord David Owen, Simon Denis, and chair Rosemary Cook

Supporting the motion were Dr Colin Heber Percy, a philosopher and author, and Simon Denis, a historian, teacher and former pupil at St John’s.  Before the debate most of the audience showed whether they were in favour or against the motion – producing a 110-51 split in favour of intervention.

Dr Heber Percy argued strongly that as a major seller of arms Britain was not an impartial force with the moral authority to intervene: “Intervention is a sales pitch and they want you to buy into it.”  

Lord Owen, foreign secretary from 1977 to 1979 and closely involved in bringing peace to former-Yugoslavia, did not argue that every intervention was right.  But he was a fierce believer in the United Nations, the legitimacy of its charter and of interventions authorised by the Security Council.

Click here to visit a view of the debate from Rhiana Mills, IB student at St Johns
In backing the motion, Simon Denis thought intervention was too often a cover for regime change and tended to leave things as bad or even worse than they were.  He thought intervention by the western, democratic powers was a thing of the past: “We’re not living, alas, in a westernised world.”  
        
Simon Denis     The Venerable Stephen Robbins     Dr Colin Heber-Percy
Stephen Robbins, who was senior army chaplain for the invasion of Iraq, admitted that not all interventions went as well as they should.  But gave impassioned support for the moral duty to deal “with the worst of humanity” and said the failure to stop the genocide in Rwanda had been “an absolute disgrace.”

After the debate the audience of over 200 levelled some pointed questions at the panellists.  Then the vote was taken again – those against military intervention increased their vote by just six votes.

Coming soon in this space: reports on the debate by two St John’s sixth formers.

Print

Brooks-Williams1
IMG8472
Sunset2
Marlborough-under-snow-from-above---Pete-Davies
1stXV-and-others-with-Mayor
Animals06
Remebrance-18-2
Roving-Crows1
Torch-2012-05-23093-
Camilla-MSM
Remebrance-18-3
Remebrance-18-1
CivicSelfie1
Christmas-Lights15-11-20097
Scouting-for-Girls7
Camilla-2012-10-19152
Bluebells-in-West-Woods-10-05-09---30
D4S0472
JazzFestSat572
Pete-Gage-Band1
Musical-Time-Machine5
George-Wilding-301
Duke-of-Kent086
Big-Bull
Town-Hall-2011-05-0308-
Snowy-High-Street
Marlborough-2013-04-18StPeters
MYFC005
D4S9273
SBJ
Civic-Service-18
4MI-2013-11-28030
Hares017cropped
White-Horse
ARKManton-2012-01-1449-
Silbury-Sunset---10-06-08---07
D812668
Mop-Fair---10-10-09---08
Sunset
IMG9097
Ogbourne
Turin-Brakes6
Tina-May5
Inquisitive-sheep-in-West-Overton
Landscape
Gordon-and-Sam
Brazier
TdB-Pewsey044